Foster Care

Parenting an Anxious Child: When Accommodations Help… and When They Hurt

September 7, 2025

One of the hardest parts of parenting children from hard places is the constant question: am I doing the right thing? Every decision feels weighted:Do I push or do I give grace? Do I set the boundary or soften it?Do I make the accommodation or hold steady? If you’re parenting a child with trauma or anxiety, […]

A call to mindfulness for moms
How to keep your anxiety from affecting your kids
How to deal with the unknowns of foster care
Now Trending:
I'm Cathleen!

I'm a foster + adoptive + bio mama to 4, and a psychotherapist in private practice.  I'm here to help you deal with all the feels on your foster care journey.  Welcome!

hello,

Ready to Feel Supported and Encouraged?

tell me more

I'd love to hop on a free call with you to find out the best way to support you!

One of the hardest parts of parenting children from hard places is the constant question: am I doing the right thing?

Every decision feels weighted:
Do I push or do I give grace?
 Do I set the boundary or soften it?
Do I make the accommodation or hold steady?

If you’re parenting a child with trauma or anxiety, you’ve likely asked yourself these questions on repeat. And you’re not alone.

Recently, one of the mamas in my Fearless Fostering community shared something that hit home for many of us:

“I’ve been working through a continuing education on parenting anxious kids, and it’s made me realize how many accommodations I’ve made for my son. With our adopted daughter, I could keep the long view in mind because adoption brought stability. But with my foster son, I find myself parenting in the unknown. I’m not sure where the line is between helpful and harmful when it comes to accommodations.”

This is such a brave, honest reflection — and one so many foster and adoptive parents will resonate with.


What Are Accommodations, Really?

In parenting, “accommodations” are the adjustments we make to help our child avoid triggers, regulate emotions, or feel safe.

Examples include:

  • Letting your child skip certain activities that feel overwhelming.

  • Changing routines to avoid meltdowns.

  • Speaking for them in social situations to ease their anxiety.

  • Allowing them to sleep in your bed because being alone feels scary.

  • Re-arranging family plans around their moods or behaviors.

On the surface, accommodations are not bad. In fact, they often spring from deep compassion. When our child is fragile, scared, or triggered, it feels natural to step in and smooth the way.

But here’s the tricky part: while short-term accommodations can soothe, too many accommodations over time can actually feed anxiety instead of healing it.


Why Accommodations Can Backfire

Psychologists often compare anxiety to a hungry monster. Every time you accommodate, you “feed the monster.” It quiets down for a moment, but soon it’s hungrier and louder than before.

Here’s why:

  • Avoidance teaches the brain the trigger is dangerous. If a child never faces the scary thing, their brain never learns it’s survivable.

  • Accommodations can shrink family life. Suddenly everything revolves around not upsetting one child, which isn’t fair to siblings or parents.

  • Parents become burned out. The constant adjusting, tiptoeing, and planning can drain you emotionally and physically.

  • Kids lose opportunities to build resilience. Struggle, when supported, is where growth happens.

This doesn’t mean you should never accommodate — it just means discernment is key.


Why It Feels Different With Trauma

For foster and adoptive parents, this is layered with trauma.

When you know your child’s backstory — the neglect, the fear, the instability — it’s easy to feel like you must protect them from everything hard.

You may also parent differently depending on permanency:

  • With an adopted child, you can see the long arc. You know you’ll still be there in five years, so you may feel steadier about holding limits.

  • With a foster child, the future feels uncertain. You may hesitate to say “no” because you fear damaging attachment in the time you do have.

This tension — between compassion for trauma and concern about enabling anxiety — is real.


Signs You May Be Over-Accommodating

Every child is unique, but here are a few signs accommodations might be tipping into the unhelpful zone:

  • Your family life feels centered around one child’s moods or anxieties.

  • Siblings are consistently missing out or resentful because of accommodations.

  • You feel anxious yourself if you don’t accommodate.

  • The child’s world seems to be shrinking rather than expanding.

  • Progress feels stalled — the same issues keep cycling.


Practical Strategies for Finding Balance

So how do you know when to accommodate and when to lean in? Here are some guiding practices:

1. Differentiate Support vs. Shielding

Ask: Am I supporting my child through this challenge, or shielding them from it entirely?

  • Support looks like: “I’ll sit with you during the first 10 minutes of Sunday school.”

  • Shielding looks like: “You never have to go at all.”

2. Use Baby Steps

Rather than an all-or-nothing approach, think gradual.

  • Instead of removing all expectations, lower them a notch.

  • Build tolerance slowly — celebrate every micro-step forward.

3. Name the Growth Out Loud

Help your child see their own resilience.

  • “I noticed you stayed in your bed two minutes longer tonight. That shows so much bravery.”

  • “You told me you were nervous, but you tried anyway. That’s huge.”

4. Check Your Own Anxiety

Sometimes, we accommodate not just for our child’s relief but for our own. It’s hard to watch our kids struggle. But remember: sitting with them through discomfort can be more healing than removing it.

5. Keep the Long Game in Mind

Even if foster care feels uncertain, remember that resilience skills go with your child wherever they live. Teaching them to face fears is a gift no matter what the case outcome is.


Supporting the Whole Family

Another important piece is remembering that accommodations don’t just affect the anxious child — they ripple across the whole household.

  • Siblings need fairness. They may not get the same accommodations, but they need to see that their needs matter too.

  • Parents need margin. If accommodations are draining you, that’s a red flag it’s time to reassess.

  • Family culture matters. Try not to let anxiety dictate the family rhythm. Instead, anchor your home in shared values: love, connection, flexibility, but also consistency.


Giving Yourself Grace

This isn’t about blame. If you’re reading this and realizing, oh wow, I’ve made a lot of accommodations, that doesn’t mean you’ve failed.

It means you’re a caring, attentive parent who’s been doing what felt right in the moment. And now, you’re noticing some of the costs. That awareness itself is powerful.

Parenting kids with anxiety and trauma is complex. There’s no perfect formula. You’ll make mistakes. You’ll course-correct. And that’s okay.


Final Encouragement

Foster and adoptive mamas, here’s what I want you to remember:

  • Making accommodations doesn’t mean you’re weak or indulgent — it means you care.

  • Scaling back accommodations doesn’t mean you’re harsh — it means you’re building resilience.

  • You are allowed to hold both compassion and boundaries.

The truth is, your child’s healing doesn’t depend on you making everything easy. It depends on you showing up consistently, with love, and guiding them toward strength one step at a time.

And you don’t have to figure that balance out alone.

Inside the Foster Mama Lifeline, we talk about real-life struggles like this every day. We unpack the messy middle together — with tools, encouragement, and a safe space to process.

Because parenting anxious kids with trauma histories is hard — but with support, it doesn’t have to feel impossible.

 Ready for that kind of support? Join the Foster Mama Lifeline today for $129/year.

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

so hot right now

Get exclusive discounts for ongoing support when you join.

You'll have instant access for a whole year once you join the Foster Mama Lifeline; you'll also get exclusive discounts on ongoing access to Cathleen through monthly Zoom support calls. 

Let's Do this!

Bonus alert!

Join the Group - sign up and get instant access to all the trauma-informed trainings, scripts and support tools. 

First:

Get the support you deserve - Hop into the Marco Polo chat starting July 1st!

Then: 

How It Works

Fearless Fostering Gift Cards Now Available!!

Fearless Fostering gift cards are available in $25, $50, and $100 increments. They can be used on any Fearless Fostering product or service of equal or lesser value and they NEVER expire! 

They're the perfect way to treat your fave foster mama!

Grab a gift card

Helping foster + adoptive moms find community, tools + confidence to thrive on their journey without sacrificing their well-being.

community
offers
About
blog

fearless fostering

follow along 
on Instagram:

SEND ME A NOTE >

get support now >

@fearless_fostering 

© fearless fostering 2021  |  Design by Tonic  

podcast