Foster Care

The Guilt of Saying No: Why Boundaries Matter in Foster Parenting

September 14, 2025

If there’s one word I hear over and over again from foster moms, it’s this: guilt. We feel guilty for not doing enough, for not being enough, for wanting rest, for saying no to one more visit, one more placement, one more request from a caseworker. And when we do say no, we often sit […]

A call to mindfulness for moms
How to keep your anxiety from affecting your kids
How to deal with the unknowns of foster care
Now Trending:
I'm Cathleen!

I'm a foster + adoptive + bio mama to 4, and a psychotherapist in private practice.  I'm here to help you deal with all the feels on your foster care journey.  Welcome!

hello,

Ready to Feel Supported and Encouraged?

tell me more

I'd love to hop on a free call with you to find out the best way to support you!

If there’s one word I hear over and over again from foster moms, it’s this: guilt.

We feel guilty for not doing enough, for not being enough, for wanting rest, for saying no to one more visit, one more placement, one more request from a caseworker. And when we do say no, we often sit with the heavy weight of second-guessing ourselves: Am I letting someone down? Am I failing as a foster parent?

But here’s the truth: boundaries are not selfish — they are essential. Without them, foster parenting will eat us alive. With them, we can actually show up more fully, more consistently, and more lovingly for the children in our care.


Why Foster Moms Struggle to Say No

Foster parenting is unique in so many ways. Unlike biological parenting, there are constant outside voices and pressures shaping our day-to-day lives: caseworkers, judges, therapists, agency rules, biological families, and the system itself.

And because we know these children have already been through so much, we want to say yes to everything — more visits, more services, more flexibility, more placements. Saying yes feels like love, like sacrifice, like the “right” thing to do.

But here’s the catch: when every yes is at our expense, no one wins.

  • Kids can sense our burnout.

  • Relationships with our partners and other children get strained.

  • We become resentful instead of present.

What looks like love on the surface can actually erode our ability to sustain this journey long term.


Why Boundaries Are Not Selfish

Think of boundaries like guardrails on a highway. They’re not there to block the journey — they’re there to keep everyone safe.

Boundaries in foster parenting might sound like:

  • Saying no to a placement that doesn’t fit your family’s capacity right now.

  • Asking for notice before visits instead of last-minute disruptions.

  • Protecting certain family rhythms (like dinner time or bedtime) as non-negotiable.

  • Taking respite when you need it, without apology.

None of these make you a “bad” foster parent. In fact, they make you a sustainable one. Because here’s the truth: burned-out moms can’t pour into their kids the way they want to. Boundaries protect not just you — but the children in your care.


The Role of Guilt

So why does it feel so terrible to say no? Guilt.

Guilt tells us:

  • “If you say no, you’re letting everyone down.”

  • “If you set limits, you’re not a good enough mom.”

  • “If you take care of yourself, you’re selfish.”

But here’s the truth: guilt is a signal, not a fact. It often shows up when we’re doing something new, like setting a boundary. Over time, the guilt fades — and peace, presence, and stability take its place.


How to Set Boundaries Without Losing Compassion

Setting boundaries doesn’t mean slamming doors or refusing to collaborate. It’s about knowing your limits and communicating them with kindness.

Here are some strategies:

1. Get Clear on Your Non-Negotiables

Write down the top 3 things your family needs to thrive — maybe it’s bedtime routines, Sunday family time, or not taking more than 2 placements at once. Protect those first.

2. Pause Before Answering

When a request comes in, practice saying: “Let me think about that and get back to you.” It gives you space to respond, not react.

3. Use Gentle but Firm Language

  • Instead of: “We can’t ever do that.”

  • Try: “Right now, that doesn’t work for our family. Here’s what we can do instead.”

4. Remind Yourself: Saying No Creates Space for Your Best Yes

Every no frees you to say yes to the things that matter most — the children already in your care, your own health, and your family’s stability.


Real-Life Examples

One foster mom in our community shared how she used to say yes to every placement call, even though her family was stretched thin. Eventually, the stress nearly broke her marriage. Learning to say, “We’re not available right now,” felt excruciating at first — but it preserved her family so they could continue fostering long-term.

Another mama realized she had said yes to last-minute visit changes so often that her other children were beginning to resent the constant disruption. Setting a boundary with the caseworker felt terrifying — but ultimately created more stability for all the kids in her home.

These stories remind us: boundaries don’t shut doors, they open the right ones.


Final Encouragement

If you feel guilty for saying no, you’re not alone. Every foster mom wrestles with this. But here’s what I want you to remember:

  • Saying no doesn’t make you selfish. It makes you sustainable.

  • Boundaries are not walls — they’re bridges that help you love from a place of strength.

  • The children in your care don’t need a perfect foster mom. They need a present one.

So the next time guilt creeps in when you set a boundary, remind yourself: I am not failing. I am protecting the space where healing can actually happen.


Call to Action

If this resonated with you, I want you to know — you don’t have to navigate the guilt and the boundaries alone.

Inside the Foster Mama Lifeline, we talk about real-life struggles like this every month. You’ll find community, encouragement, and practical tools to help you set boundaries without the guilt.

💛 Join us for just $129/year and get instant access to the support you’ve been craving.

+ show Comments

- Hide Comments

add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

so hot right now

Get exclusive discounts for ongoing support when you join.

You'll have instant access for a whole year once you join the Foster Mama Lifeline; you'll also get exclusive discounts on ongoing access to Cathleen through monthly Zoom support calls. 

Let's Do this!

Bonus alert!

Join the Group - sign up and get instant access to all the trauma-informed trainings, scripts and support tools. 

First:

Get the support you deserve - Hop into the Marco Polo chat starting July 1st!

Then: 

How It Works

Fearless Fostering Gift Cards Now Available!!

Fearless Fostering gift cards are available in $25, $50, and $100 increments. They can be used on any Fearless Fostering product or service of equal or lesser value and they NEVER expire! 

They're the perfect way to treat your fave foster mama!

Grab a gift card

Helping foster + adoptive moms find community, tools + confidence to thrive on their journey without sacrificing their well-being.

community
offers
About
blog

fearless fostering

follow along 
on Instagram:

SEND ME A NOTE >

get support now >

@fearless_fostering 

© fearless fostering 2021  |  Design by Tonic  

podcast